Is it possible to be really in love with two people at the same time? Both of these guys are like a perfect match for me. I even tried using your app and they scored almost identical. Now what? How do I decide?
When you picture your life without one of them, with whom are you more upset? If you think long term and not just what's involved today, e.g. family, children, etc., the decision will come to you. To answer your question, yes, it's certainly possible to love two other people deeply. Be patient.