http://ask.fm/MajedJarrar/answers/139384344898 Some of the very famous ask.fm scholars are becoming more self-important each day. Your explanation does not apply to them. We have many examples of scholars who deal with such things in a way where we could see they guard themselves from (3ujb)
Your argument has too many assumptions to deem it correct akhi. You are assuming you know who the scholars are, and have studied how they all interacted with the public versus with their own students, then compared it with the current ask fm people, and analysed their intentions, and verified they are not guarding themselves from their own ego, before reaching this conclusion.
Simple question: is the way of answering public questions followed by some ask.fm peeps similar to the way some scholars of the past? Yes? Case closed.
What you might see as condescension, is a disciplinary path that numerous scholars have taken against the laity who ask arrogantly or disrespectfully. If they spot something wrong in your language or manners, they will likely not disregard it. In fact, some may disregard the question you're asking and focus on treating that ailment.
Assessing your personality as a core part of the question is the epitome of Fiqh. Ibn Abbas had two people ask him in the same day about the repentance from murder, he gave opposite answers because one came with shame and the other came with rage.
Scholars are not Google bots, they are not there just to serve your curiosity. They care about your overall well-being.
Simple question: is the way of answering public questions followed by some ask.fm peeps similar to the way some scholars of the past? Yes? Case closed.
What you might see as condescension, is a disciplinary path that numerous scholars have taken against the laity who ask arrogantly or disrespectfully. If they spot something wrong in your language or manners, they will likely not disregard it. In fact, some may disregard the question you're asking and focus on treating that ailment.
Assessing your personality as a core part of the question is the epitome of Fiqh. Ibn Abbas had two people ask him in the same day about the repentance from murder, he gave opposite answers because one came with shame and the other came with rage.
Scholars are not Google bots, they are not there just to serve your curiosity. They care about your overall well-being.
Liked by:
Ahmed Maher Hegazy
