aww thank you grace! I appreciate it very much BUT.. TBH.. i also wear eyeshadow and powder too :| i swear i'm an oily mess. I even wore primer, and a big jumno eyeliner pencil by nyx as my base. oh lawd T.T i think the best i've used so far is probably the milani, since it smears just a lil.
MAYBE ITS THE JUMBO PENCIL. DONT USE PENCIL! i hate pencil cuz it smears like ugh! just try to use good eyeshadow maybe even a carefully chosen primer. i love using the h20 proof by wet n wild hehe it works for me